Why Beginners Improve Faster Than They Think They Do
Here's something I see in my art groups all the time. Someone puts their pencil down, looks at their page, and sighs. "I don't think I'm getting any better."
So I ask them to look at or show me the very first drawing they did, and I put it next to the one they've just finished. The table goes quiet, sometimes there's a "wow"... Because the difference is enormous. They just couldn't see it.
You might know this feeling. You've been drawing for a few weeks, or a few months, and it all feels the same. Wobbly lines. Faces that don't quite work. A mug that looks suspiciously like a bucket. So you decide nothing's changing.
I'd like to (gently) argue with that. Beginners improve faster than they think, and the reason you can't tell is much kinder than you'd expect.
Why Beginners Improve Faster Than They Think (and Why It Doesn't Feel That Way)
The biggest jumps in drawing happen early.
In your first few weeks you're learning to actually look. Where an edge really sits. How big one shape is compared with the next. Where the shadow falls. Each of those is a proper leap, and you can make them quickly.
But here's the catch. You don't compare your drawing with the drawing you did last month. You compare it with the picture in your head. And the picture in your head is always better than anything your hand can make right now.
That gap is the whole problem. It's not that you aren't improving. It's that the finish line moves every time you get closer to it.
Your Eye Gets Better Before Your Hand Does
This is the bit I wish someone had told me years ago, even when I was at school! Your eye improves first. Your hand catches up later. It makes your art progress so much more understandable!
So a few weeks in, you start noticing things you couldn't see before. The proportions are off. The shading is flat. The eyes are too high. It feels like you're getting worse, because you keep finding more wrong with your drawings.
You're not getting worse. You're getting sharper. Being able to spot what's wrong is the progress. Week one you, the one who thought the bucket-mug was fine, couldn't have told you what was off about it at all.
It's very common to want to hide your sketchbook at exactly this point. Please don't! The flaws you can see now are the ones you'll fix next, and that's a very good place to be.
The Three Stages Nobody Tells You About
There's a bit of psychology that explains this nicely. Back in the 1960s, two psychologists, Paul Fitts and Michael Posner, described three stages of learning any skill.
The first is the thinking stage. You're doing everything consciously, making lots of mistakes, and it feels clumsy. The second is the practising stage, where the mistakes get fewer and things start to flow. The third is the autopilot stage, where it's become so automatic you barely think about it.
Almost every adult beginner I start to teach is in stage one. And stage one always feels worse than it is, because your whole brain is busy. You haven't got spare attention left to notice you're improving.
I always tell new members the same thing. If you feel clumsy, that's not a sign you're doing it wrong. It's a sign you're doing it. Clumsy is simply what learning feels like from the inside, and it fades faster than you'd think.
Joshua Foer later popularised a name for what can happen at the far end of those stages, the "OK plateau". It's where you get good enough, switch to autopilot, and stop pushing. You are nowhere near that yet. If your drawings feel messy, you're right in the useful part.
How to Actually See Your Own Progress
You can't trust a feeling. But you can trust evidence. A few simple habits make progress visible:
Date every drawing, even the ones you hate. A date turns a bad day into a data point.
Keep your rough pages. Don't bin them. They're the proof you'll want in three months.
Redraw the same thing once a month. A mug, your hand, a pear. Same subject, same pencil, side by side.
If you tried my timed sketch back in September, now's the perfect time to dig it out and draw it again. I'd love to know what you notice.
And if you'd like a bit more reassurance on timelines, I wrote about what you can really expect in the first three months of drawing. I also wrote about why your drawings look different from one day to the next, which is a big part of why progress is so hard to judge on your own.
Beginners Improve Faster When Someone Else Can See It Too
I'll be honest. It's far easier to spot your own progress when someone else points it out. Someone in my art groups will say, "Oh, look at the way you've done that shading now." And the person who did it looks up, completely surprised.
That's the thing about a second pair of eyes. They don't have your picture-in-the-head problem. They can only see what's on the page, and what's on the page is better than you think.
It's one of the reasons I built Create: the way I did. When you're drawing alongside other people, someone always notices the improvement you've been missing.
A Welcome, and a Thank You
If you joined us inside Create last month, welcome. I'm so glad you're here. And thank you to everyone who came along to the live sessions, drew with us, and asked such good questions.
The doors have closed for this round. If you didn't join this time, that's absolutely fine, and there's no pressure at all. You can start with KickstART, my free five-day course, whenever you like. It's open all year, and it's a gentle way to see your own progress for yourself.
Now tell me. What can you do now that you couldn't do in September? Pop it in the comments. I'd love to hear.
Debbie x
Comments